Live
India's New Zealand tour: Why it matters more than the scoreline, says K R Nayar
A new column argues that India's real gain from the New Zealand trip is knowing what kind of team it needs, not winning every match.

Ahead of India's tour of New Zealand, cricket writer K R Nayar says the real prize is clarity, not a clean sweep. In his column, he argues that India should return from the tour knowing exactly what sort of team it wants to build for the future.
Nayar points to a lot of change around the side. New players and new combinations have been tried, the captaincy is split for this tour, and V V S Laxman stepped in when head coach Gautam Gambhir was resting or unavailable. That has fed talk that India could end up with split coaches too. A new selection panel has also taken charge, with Pragyan Ojha as chairperson and Ramesh Powar as a new member.
The recent West Indies series is his warning sign. It was expected to be an easy assignment, yet India won the ODIs only 2-1 and the T20Is finished 2-2. For Nayar, that raises a simple question: India has plenty of good cricketers, but does it have enough match-winners, people who can deliver when a game is on a knife-edge?
He notes that India's talent pool is huge. India A tours, age-group cricket, state cricket and the IPL all offer routes to the national team, and a player can reach the door quickly. But Nayar asks whether so much competition is also creating insecurity.
His worry is about how players behave under that pressure. A batter who fears losing his place may play safe instead of playing the shots that win games. A bowler may hold back rather than attack for wickets, because one expensive spell could send him back to domestic cricket. Competition makes players work harder, Nayar says, but fear can make them play not to lose.
He also questions where leadership sits. In his view, the captain does not look like the face and voice of the team, while the coach appears to have huge influence over selection and tactics, from workload management to batting order and field placing. That, he suggests, turns the captain into more of an executioner than a leader. He adds that selectors need to know when to change things and when to resist, because experimentation has an expiry date.
Nayar says the New Zealand tour should show whether the recent changes are working, because tough opponents expose weaknesses. It should also show whether India's depth is real. Note that this is an opinion piece, so these are the columnist's views, not official positions.
Read the original column on Rediff.